| Name | Record | Overall Standing |
|---|---|---|
| J.D. | 11-6 (.647) | 1 |
| Chad | 11-6 (.647) | 1 |
| Captain | 9-6 (.600) | 3 |
| Cat | 9-8 (.529) | 4 |
| Uncle Giant | 8-9 (.471) | 5 |
| Lorelei | 8-9 (.471) | 5 |
| Eddie | 4-6 (.400) | 6 |
| Grammy | 6-11 (.353) | 7 |
| Team Scheme | Walkers vs Davises |
|---|---|
| Challenge Theme | Picked from a container |
| Winners | Walkers |
| Games | Ping-Pan-Pong, Tongue Tied, Chameleon, Snow Family, |
| Teams | |
| Walkers | Davises |
| Chad | J.D. |
| Cat | Grammy |
| Lorelei | Uncle Giant |
| Eddie | |
| Team Scheme | Drew cards |
|---|---|
| Challenge Theme | Picked from a container |
| Winners | Red Cards |
| Games | On the Dot, Cribbage, Puzzles, Marshmellow Mayhem, Roly Poly |
| Teams | |
| Black Cards | Red Cards |
| Chad | J.D. |
| Grammy | Cat |
| Uncle Giant | Lorelei |
| Eddie | |
| Team Scheme | Parents/Non-Parents |
|---|---|
| Challenge Theme | Picked from a container |
| Winners | Parents |
| Games | I Spy Christmas Tree, Sip-Sip-Suck, TP Roll Up, Everybody Knows, Egg Smash |
| Teams | |
| Parents | Non-Parents |
| Cat | J.D. |
| Chad | Uncle Giant |
| Captain | Lorelei |
| Grammy | Eddie |
| Team Scheme | Tie breaking team captains |
|---|---|
| Challenge Theme | Picked from a container |
| Winners | Turkey Catchers |
| Games | Pencil Flip, I Spy Christmas Tree, Flip Tac Toe, Reindeer Games, Chow Crown |
| Teams | |
| Turkey Catchers | Turkey Tossers |
| Cat | Grammy |
| J.D. | Chad |
| Uncle Giant | Captain |
| Lorelei | Eddie |
| Team Scheme | Old-Young pairings |
|---|---|
| Challenge Theme | Names From A Hat Personal Games |
| Winners | Oreo Music Box |
| Games | Throwback Heads-Up, Tenzi Extreme, Oreo Head Catch, Christmas Drawing, Baconator |
| Teams | |
| Oreo Music Box | Bacon |
| Captain | Chad |
| Uncle Giant | J.D. |
| Lorelei | Eddie |
| Cat | Grammy |
| Team Scheme | Top-Bottom/Middle |
|---|---|
| Challenge Theme | Names From A Hat Personal Games |
| Winners | Top-Bottom |
| Games | Move the M&M's, Santa's Christmas Cookies, Builder Boom, Imagine, Bounce |
| Teams | |
| Top-Bottom | Middle |
| Chad | Captain |
| J.D. | Uncle Giant |
| Grammy | Eddie |
| Cat | Lorelei |
| Team Scheme | Gender Inequality |
|---|---|
| Challenge Theme | High Card Personal Games |
| Winners | The Boys |
| Games | The Great Dalmuti, Candy Cane Drop, Christmas Tree Punch,
|
| Teams | |
| Boys | Girls |
| Eddie | Steph |
| Captain | Lorelei |
| J.D. | Cat |
| Chad | Grammy |
| Uncle Giant | Meredith |
| Team Scheme | Lowest Pick Others |
|---|---|
| Challenge Theme | Personal Games |
| Winners | Team Eddie |
| Games | Ten Thousand, I Spy, King of Tokyo, |
| Teams | |
| Team Steph | Team Eddie |
| Steph | Eddie |
| Captain | Uncle Giant |
| Cat | J.D. |
| Chad | Grammy |
| Lorelei | Meredith (Honory) |
| Team Scheme | Team Captains |
|---|---|
| Challenge Theme | Personal Games |
| Winners | The Captain & the Girls |
| Games | 20+1, Imagine If, Christmas Bowling, Translations, Sudoku |
| Teams | |
| The Captain & the Girls | Team Winners |
| Steph | Eddie |
| Captain | Uncle Giant |
| Cat | J.D. |
| Lorelei | Chad |
| Meredith (Honory) | Grammy |
| Team Scheme | Picked out of a hat |
|---|---|
| Challenge Theme | Personal Games |
| Winners | Team Awesome |
| Games | Spiderman Uno Water Pong Cups Heads Up Christmas Plate Drawing Makin' Bacon Dice |
| Teams | |
| Awesome | Plan B |
| Chad | Eddie |
| J.D. | Cat |
| Lorelei | Uncle Giant |
| Captain | Grammy |
| Team Scheme | Secret |
|---|---|
| Challenge Theme | Secret |
| Winners | Team B |
| Games | Mystery Board Game Bags Game Day Decision Spelling Bee Eggstreme Separation |
| Teams | |
| A | B |
| Grammy | Uncle Giant |
| Cat | Chad |
| Katie | Lorelei |
| J.D. | Captain |
| Team Scheme | Coin Flip |
|---|---|
| Challenge Theme | Misc. |
| Winners | Tails |
| Games | Candy Cane Rudolphs Magnetic Rocket Toss Are You Smarter Than a Fifth Grader House of Cards Hong Kong |
| Teams | |
| Heads | Tails |
| Captain | Grammy |
| Uncle Giant | J.D. |
| Cat | Chad |
| Eddie (Honory) | Lorelei |
| Team Scheme | Agism |
|---|---|
| Challenge Theme | Misc. |
| Winners | The Old Timers |
| Games | Soccer Croquet Trivia Minute-To-Win-It Nut Stacker Minute-To-Win-It Candy Cane Grab Present Race Tie-Buster: 31 |
| Teams | |
| Old Timers | Youngins |
| Captain | Uncle Giant |
| Grammy | J.D. |
| Cat | Jenelle |
| Chad | Lorelei |
| Eddie (Honory) | |
| Team Scheme | Marriage |
|---|---|
| Challenge Theme | Misc. |
| Winners | Unmarried Team |
| Games | Boom Blox Darts Cubs Yahtzee |
| Teams | |
| Maried | Unmaried |
| Captain | Uncle Giant |
| Grammy | J.D. |
| Cat | Lorelei |
| Chad | |
| Team Scheme | Captains |
|---|---|
| Challenge Theme | Golf |
| Winners | Captain's Team |
| Games | Gator Golf Ladder GolfWii Mini Golf |
| Teams | |
| Lorelei's Team | Captain's Team |
| Lorelei | Captain |
| Grammy | J.D. |
| Uncle Giant | Cat |
| Jenelle | Chad |
| Team Scheme | Employment |
|---|---|
| Challenge Theme | Misc. |
| Winners | Jobs |
| Games | Wii Bowling Table-Top Shuffleboard Family Fued DVD Wii TV Game Show |
| Teams | |
| Jobs | No Jobs |
| Uncle Giant | Captain |
| Grammy | Cat |
| Chad | Lorelei |
| J.D. | |
| Team Scheme | Gender |
|---|---|
| Challenge Theme | Scavenger Hunt |
| Winners | Boys |
| Games | Scavenger Hunt at the outlet mall |
| Teams | |
| Girls | Boys |
| Lorelei | Captain |
| Grammy | J.D. |
| Cat | Uncle Giant |
| Chad | |